Research guide • Agency selection

How should a business choose an AI visibility agency?

If you're comparing GEO, AEO or AI SEO consultants, ask how they investigate real buyer questions, verify source evidence and report useful outcomes—not merely whether they display an impressive score.

Ask what the agency will actually test

Does the provider research questions from your buyers, industry and region? Are the prompts written down? Is the platform and repeat-test scope clear? Does the agency distinguish direct recommendations from incidental mentions?

Ask how citations are reviewed

A credible investigation opens linked sources, checks relevance, and records both what can be verified and what cannot. Be cautious with claims that an agency knows exactly why a proprietary AI model produced an answer.

Ask what is delivered

Request a sample report structure: executive summary, prompt panel, observed answers, competitors, citations, technical/site findings, prioritized actions and follow-up measurement instructions. Separate a free snapshot from a paid source-level investigation.

Look for real implementation ability

The team should understand technical SEO, accessible content, information architecture, entity consistency and legitimate third-party corroboration. A score without an action plan is rarely sufficient.

Investigate their evidence and incentives

Check real publications, named team experience where available, public methodology and independently verifiable work. Question self-awarded agency rankings, vague case studies and guaranteed “ChatGPT first position” offers.

Choose outcomes that matter

Agree how work will be evaluated: verified technical improvements, source quality, qualified enquiries, trustworthy referral analytics and repeatable research. A positive change in one answer is not proof of attributable business lift.

Compare us using the same criteria

MentionGauge publishes its manual research process and distinguishes observations from explanations. You can use this checklist when evaluating any provider, including us.

Start with the evidence

Know what AI answers actually show.

Request a scoped manual audit to understand how your business appears across relevant AI-assisted search experiences and what can be improved.